Is low carb an extreme diet?

January 6 2017 by in About membership, Dr. Jason Fung, Dr. Rangan Chatterjee, Dr. Sarah Hallberg, Dr. Ted Naiman, Low carb & high fat, Low Carb Vail, Q&A

7,855 views

Watch Dr. Rangan Chatterjee answer the question above (transcript). The full Q&A video – with answers from four more doctors – is available, with captions and transcript, with a free trial or membership.

Is low carb an extreme diet? – doctors answer common questions

Start your free membership trial to get instant access to this and over 190 other low-carb TV videos. Plus Q&A with experts and our awesome new low-carb meal planner service, etc.

More Q&A videos

Everything in moderation?
05:44
What’s the point of low carb, shouldn’t we all just try to eat everything in moderation? Top low-carb doctors answer this question.
Is low carb bad for exercise?
02:45
Can you exercise on a low-carb diet? Top low-carb doctors answer this question.
Does the brain need carbohydrates?
05:56
Doesn’t the brain need carbohydrates? Doctors answer common questions.
Is low carb bad for the kidneys?
04:25
Can a low-carb diet potentially be bad for the kidneys? Or is it just a myth, like most other low-carb fears?
Can fasting be problematic for women?
05:54
Can fasting be problematic for women? We'll get the answers from top low-carb experts here.
Are there potential dangers with a low-carb diet?
09:30
Can a low-carb diet potentially be dangerous? And if so – how? Top low-carb doctors answer these questions.
What is the main benefit of low carb?
02:52
What exactly is the greatest benefit of low carb? Doctors give their top answer.
Is there a link between low carb and eating disorders?
03:16
Is there a link between low carb and eating disorders? In this episode of the women's questions series, we focus on eating disorders and a low-carb diet.
Is low carb bad for the environment?
07:09
Won’t low carb contribute to global warming and pollution? Top low-carb doctors answer this question.
Women's questions introduction
01:36
In this video series, you can find expert views on some of your top questions about low-carb and women's health.
Why is low carb important to you?
04:16
Why is low carb important to Dr. Rangan Chatterjee and Dr. Sarah Hallberg?
Can you get depressed on low carb?
02:42
Can you get depressed on a low-carb diet? Top low-carb doctors answer this question.
Isn't weight loss all about counting calories?
03:14
To lose weight, you just eat fewer calories than you burn. Is it really that simple? Top low-carb doctors answer.
Can low carb make menopause easier?
03:56
Can low-carb make menopause easier? We'll get the answer from top low-carb experts here.
Is low carb bad for the thyroid?
06:28
Does a low-carb diet impact thyroid function? Top low-carb doctors answer this question.
Is low carb bad for gut bacteria?
02:14
Can a low-carb diet be potentially harmful to your gut microbiome?
Is saturated fat bad?
07:29
Low carb is great. But could the saturated fat clog your arteries and kill you? Top low-carb doctors answer this question.
How do you maximize your health?
06:01
What do you need to do, as a woman, to maximize your health? In this video, we take a deep dive into all the important pillars that affect our health the most.
Can low carb and keto help with PMS?
02:10
Could a low-carb diet help with PMS symptoms? In this episode of the women's questions series, the experts talk about hormone fluctuations.
Can exercise be problematic for women?
02:48
Can exercise be problematic for women? Is a low-carb diet beneficial for women who exercise? And what kind of exercise typically suits women the best?
Do you need more carbs when breastfeeding?
04:27
In this episode of the women’s questions series, we hear from several experts on their view on carbs for breastfeeding women.

Low carb for beginners

5 comments

1
Daniel
May 13 2017
Completely agree with you. The problem is that people think it's extreme because they don't understand how harmful refined carbs are. And also don't understand how effective low carb diets are.
They've been brainwashed for 50 years. I think it's more extreme to try to diet eating the foods that make you hungry, but that is what people do.
2
Geraldine
June 10
Truth! I am 70 years old, working an extremely physical and mentally demanding job and can honestly say that it is due to my low carb high fat diet!
3
Peggy Holloway
July 6
I've been eating lowcarb for nearly 20 years. What's extreme about eating meat, eggs, some dairy and fresh vegetables and avoiding foods that make me sick, exhausted, and unsatisfied?
4
Beverley
July 8
I am actually a bit confused about these videos. Its always about people with allergies that are mentioned. Not everyone has an allergy to carbs. It's also the quality of the carbs. There is a big difference in pastries, cakes, pasta and wild or brown rice. People also have dairy allergies and cannot tolerate eggs,milk, cream or cheese. It's common sense that if you have an allergy to a food you don't eat it. My cholesterol has increased over 2 points since eating butter, full cream cheese, cream and coconut oil. So to me I'm actually unhealthier now than I was when I ate my brown rice and wholewheat bread. And everything in moderation? It always worked for me. Healthy eating and if I wanted a sweet I had one. Not a bucket full. And I am a healthy weight and never had a weight problem. So what advice would you give me now I thought I would be better off but I've been warned I will need cholesterol meds soon.

Reply: #5
5
Reply to comment #4 by Beverley
Kristin Parker Team Diet Doctor
July 9

I am actually a bit confused about these videos. Its always about people with allergies that are mentioned. Not everyone has an allergy to carbs. It's also the quality of the carbs. There is a big difference in pastries, cakes, pasta and wild or brown rice. People also have dairy allergies and cannot tolerate eggs,milk, cream or cheese. It's common sense that if you have an allergy to a food you don't eat it. My cholesterol has increased over 2 points since eating butter, full cream cheese, cream and coconut oil. So to me I'm actually unhealthier now than I was when I ate my brown rice and wholewheat bread. And everything in moderation? It always worked for me. Healthy eating and if I wanted a sweet I had one. Not a bucket full. And I am a healthy weight and never had a weight problem. So what advice would you give me now I thought I would be better off but I've been warned I will need cholesterol meds soon.

Total cholesterol and LDL are generally not as important as triglycerides and HDL. You can read our guide to cholesterol here - https://www.dietdoctor.com/low-carb/cholesterol-basics

More Q&A videos

More

5 comments

Leave a reply Cancel reply