Does coffee raise blood sugar? Preliminary findings

July 26 2017 by , medical review by in Blood sugar, Coffee, Experiment

A few weeks ago, I started an experiment to better understand how different foods and lifestyle decisions impact blood sugar, using a constant-glucose-monitoring device.

Right now, I’m testing what effect drinking coffee has on blood-sugar levels.

Here’s the preliminary data:

coffe-blood-sugar-premliminary

The blue line is the blood glucose on a day I drank coffee. The red line is on a day without coffee. As you can see, the blood-sugar levels are on average higher when drinking coffee than when not (I added nothing to the coffee).

To reduce the probability that this difference is random, I’ll repeat the experiment this week.

What do you think will happen? On days when drinking coffee will the blood sugar be (on average) higher, lower or the same? Leave your guess in the comments below.

We’ll share our findings in a few days.

Earlier experiments

Are you interested in our earlier tests? Check out the series:

Advanced low-carb topics

MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
Common mistakes on low carb
15:47
Do you have a hard time losing weight on low carb or keto? Then perhaps you're making one of the common mistakes.
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
Weight control – calories or insulin
36:26
Is weight loss controlled by calories in and calories out? Or is our body weight carefully regulated by hormones?
MEMBERS ONLY
45:29
Although it is new in popularity, people have been practicing a carnivore diet for decades, and possibly centuries. Does that mean it is safe and without concern?
A low-carb diet for T2D reversal – Dr. Sarah Hallberg
34:15
What is the best approach to type 2 diabetes reversal? In this presentation, Sarah takes us on a deep-dive into the matter and she puts studies and evidence under the microscope.
Diet Doctor Podcast #7 – Megan Ramos
54:01
In the seventh episode of Diet Doctor Podcast, Megan Ramos, co-director at IDM program, talks about intermittent fasting, diabetes and her work together with Dr. Jason Fung at the IDM clinic.
Ketones: the metabolic advantage
37:04
Can ketones create a possible metabolic advantage?
Do you need to check your ketones?
22:19
Should you measure ketones on a keto diet? Dr. Westman guides you through situations when measuring is beneficial – and when it's not.
MEMBERS ONLY
The cause of obesity and diabetes
45:52
Why do we get fat – and what can we do about it? Iconic science-writer Gary Taubes answers these questions.

Popular now

The keto bread
01:27
Do you miss bread on a keto low-carb diet? Then you’ll love this!
Diet Doctor Podcast - The importance of protein
1:23:41
Protein may be the most important nutrient for health and weight loss. In this episode, we discuss the importance and practical aspects of eating enough protein with three of our experts at DietDoctor.com.
Diet Doctor Podcast #46 with Dom D'Agustino, PhD
25:00
You can't look at the world of ketone research without seeing the impact of Dr. D'Agostino. Dom is the leading authority of how ketogenic diets and exogenous ketones impact brain health and function.
MEMBERS ONLY
Diet Doctor Podcast #25 – Alison Gannett
1:06:21
Alison went from winning championships as an extreme skier to facing her own mortality with brain cancer. Fortunately, 6 years later, she is thriving and now is an oncology diet coach to help people use a ketogenic diet as well as comprehensive lifestyle changes to augment other potential cancer therapies.
Diet Doctor Podcast #63 with Ben Bikman, PhD
1:11:33
Insulin resistance is killing us. Professor Ben Bikman wants you to know why that is and what we can do about it.
Diet Doctor Podcast #78 — Vegetable oils: Are they healthy?
1:32:03
Some authorities promote vegetable oils as a health food, but others see them as a clear danger to our health. How do we make sense of the disparate views? Our panel of experts weighs in and helps us put things in perspective.
My low-carb story with Marc Gossange
03:01
After living somewhat of a high-carb life and then living in France for a few years enjoying croissants and freshly baked baguettes, Marc was diagnosed with type 2 diabetes.
MEMBERS ONLY
58:42
Diet Doctor Podcast #64 with Jason Fung
1:07:58
Dr. Jason Fung is well known for pioneering the use of fasting as a medical intervention to aid weight loss and treat diabetes. In his new book, The Cancer Code, Dr. Fung applies that same approach to cancer.
Diet Doctor Podcast #62 with Gary Taubes
1:09:51
Gary Taubes is back, employing his strong investigative journalism skills to help us rethink weight loss and make a case for ketogenic diets. Join me for a fascinating interview about his new book, The Case for Keto.
MEMBERS ONLY
My success story with Kenneth Russell
02:52
When Kenneth turned 50, he realized that he wouldn't make it to 60 the way he was going.
My success story with Chuck Hicks
02:39
At nearly 500 lbs (230 kg) Chuck could barely move at all anymore. It wasn’t until he found a keto diet that thing started to change.
MEMBERS ONLY
Let's get moving #4: Lunges
03:20
How do you lunge? What's the best way to do supported or walking lunges? Watch this video for this great exercise for the legs, glutes, and back.
MEMBERS ONLY
"Humans are not broken by default"
15:22
What is it like practicing as a low-carb doctor in Germany? Is the medical community there aware of the power of dietary interventions?
A low-carb story with Dr. Sanjeev Balakrishnan
01:59
How can you as a doctor treat patients with type 2 diabetes? Dr. Sanjeev Balakrishnan learned the answer to this question seven years ago. Check out this video for all the details!
MEMBERS ONLY
Did the introduction of the dietary guidelines start the obesity epidemic?
35:12
Did the introduction of the dietary guidelines start the obesity epidemic?
MEMBERS ONLY
Can low carb make it fun to be a doctor?
36:47
Dr. Unwin about getting his patients off medications and making a true difference in their lives using low carb.

Low-carb basics

MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
Low-carb tips with team Diet Doctor – Traveling
08:05
How do you stay low carb when traveling? Watch this episode to find out!
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
A global food revolution
34:30
The mistakes behind the obesity epidemic and how we can fix them together, empowering people everywhere to revolutionize their health.
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
7 tips to make low carb simple
09:41
The star of the BBC series Doctor in the House, Dr. Rangan Chatterjee, gives you seven tips that will make low carb easy.
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
Women's questions introduction
01:36
In this video series, you can find expert views on some of your top questions about low-carb and women's health.
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY

Q&A videos

MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
Women's questions introduction
01:36
In this video series, you can find expert views on some of your top questions about low-carb and women's health.
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
Is low carb bad for gut bacteria?
02:14
Can a low-carb diet be potentially harmful to your gut microbiome?
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
Is saturated fat bad?
07:29
Low carb is great. But could the saturated fat clog your arteries and kill you? Top low-carb doctors answer this question.
MEMBERS ONLY

54 comments

1
Karla
July 26 2017
Are you drinking black coffee (really, the ONLY way to drink coffee)? :-)

Reply: #9
2
Tracie
July 26 2017
Do you think it's a significant difference or a slight difference?

Is 60 a good blood sugar number or is that low?

Reply: #11
3
Nicole
July 26 2017
I believe its very individualized on how coffee impacts a person. For instance, I can't drink coffee or anything with caffeine in it. It literally feels like my intestines are rotting on the inside when I drink it. It took years to discover it was coffee and tea that caused the painful inflammation and I don't know anyone else who experiences this. Due to this - I know it would raise my blood glucose response. But I see so many other people, and it does nothing to them, just like ingesting sweeteners (like stevia, xylitol etc.) has no impact on my blood glucose.

But interesting work!
4
Marketa
July 26 2017
I tested my blood glucose for coffee for a few weeks and I saw no difference. Only I slept worse.
5
Elwin
July 26 2017
I am a retired Paramedic who has drank coffee in excess all my life
Like a lot of Information that was preached on weight loss we were told that coffee was not a problem, WELL, I joined the Diet Doctor and I am following the LCHF diet I do not cheat I am a T2 Diabetic on Insulin Injections 4 times a day
I have lowered my A1C from 8 to 6 and reduced my Insulin Injections by 2 a day
I get very discouraged when I get a High reading now. So I look back to see what went wrong What did I do to have this Increase and the CULPRIT IS COFFEE
This site has great Information on all aspects of weight loss But I need more information on a T2 trying to reduce Insulin Injections another Culprit in weight control: My weight problem ballooned when I was put on Lantus Long Acting Insulin
My weight problem ballooned when I was put on Lantus Long acting Insulin

Replies: #10, #19
6
Etai
July 26 2017
Did you eat the same things on both of those days? It looks like your blood sugar on the day you drank the coffee was already higher prior to drinking it and on the non-coffee day your sugar level dropped prior to the time you would have drank the coffee. So it makes me wonder if there is some other factor involved.

Reply: #12
7
Shaun
July 26 2017
Hi, there, are you testing for differences, if any, between effects of regular vs. decaf? Is it coffee affecting blood glucose, or is it caffeine? I read of one study that found that caffeine, and not just coffee, impacts lipid metabolism: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/0026049568900541

Would be interesting to know if there are similar differences between regular and decaf w.r.t. blood glucose levels.

Reply: #8
8
Reply to comment #7 by Shaun
Ann Whitfield
July 26 2017
I'd love to know this too
9
Reply to comment #1 by Karla
Bjarte Bakke Team Diet Doctor
July 26 2017
Normally I drink my coffee with cream, but for this experiment I drink it black.
10
Reply to comment #5 by Elwin
BobM
July 26 2017
Elwin, go to Dr. Fung's website: https://intensivedietarymanagement.com/blog/

Insulin causes insulin resistance.

Reply: #17
11
Reply to comment #2 by Tracie
Bjarte Bakke Team Diet Doctor
July 26 2017
It's a little low compared to the average person, but I'm in ketosis - and get most of my energy from fat - so lowish blood sugar isn't an issue for me.
12
Reply to comment #6 by Etai
Bjarte Bakke Team Diet Doctor
July 26 2017
I didn't eat anything during the experiment.
13
BobM
July 26 2017
There are many issues with this. Your blood sugar was higher before you drank the coffee.

I've tried to test this myself, but there are too many variables, not the least of which that the blood sugar monitors have a lot of errors. If coffee has an effect, it's subtle. I've taken my blood sugar in the morning, then had coffee, then taken my blood sugar about an hour afterwards. Sometimes it does up slightly, but most times, it goes down.

What would be interesting to see was if there was an insulin effect. That would also affect blood sugar. Maybe coffee reduces insulin? That would yield a higher blood sugar, but would cause less hunger.

Reply: #15
14
John K
July 26 2017
Very cool. Thanks for posting this.

This is one day's data for each case? It would be good to have a bunch of days of data to work with since there can be significant variability in glucose on any given day. And we see that here in blue which is bouncing around all over the place even before you have your coffee. Really, both of them are moving around a fair amount.

Reply: #16
15
Reply to comment #13 by BobM
Bjarte Bakke Team Diet Doctor
July 26 2017
I agree BobM - it's not possible conclude based on this experiment (and it's a n=1).

I repeated the experiment yesterday and today - will probably share the results this week.

Do you know of a simple and reliable way of measuring insulin levels several times during the day?
16
Reply to comment #14 by John K
Bjarte Bakke Team Diet Doctor
July 26 2017
Agree John.
17
Reply to comment #10 by BobM
Elwin
July 26 2017
Thank You, Bob M
I have been to Dr. Fung's Site I find the Information more confusing
He does not give out Individual help to Insulin Problems Which is understandable, He refers you to your Doctor and I have one who is not in agreement with LCHF diets or reversing T2 Diabetes
Like many, We go it alone
18
Lorraine
July 26 2017
Elwin -

These people can help you:

https://www.virtahealth.com/

Best of luck!
19
Reply to comment #5 by Elwin
Bjarte Bakke Team Diet Doctor
July 26 2017
Elwin,

Check out https://www.dietdoctor.com/diabetes

Reply: #26
20
Chris
July 26 2017
It looks to me as though one could interpret the above results as coffee assisting in keeping the blood sugar stable, which usually is beneficial, especially if you were doing a daily intermittent fast since it would seem to lower feelings of hunger.
21
LowCarbArcher
July 26 2017
Wait, was your diet exactly the same for the two days? You day nothing about what else you consumed.

Reply: #39
22
Tobias
July 26 2017
If you look at the graph, it shows that raising and lowering of blood sugar starts already before you consume or not consume the coffee. I wouldn't be surprised if the results next time can be just the opposite.

Reply: #40
23
Dr. Kenneth Solomon
July 26 2017
Actually if you haven't consumed any food during this time your blood glucose is at a healthier level with the caffeine (coffee). Your levels without it actual border on hypoglycemia. There has been a great deal of data testing caffeine (black coffee) and its effects on blood sugar. The results have been either neutral or a positive effect, meaning more often in the normal range.

Reply: #41
24
Wie Pan
July 26 2017
This is very unscientific and as such quite a useless set of data. As a minimum you want to share what other variables that you control or don't. There are many factors that can contribute to glucose level. Also, like you said n=1 is very limited data. I wish Diet Doctor can be a more credible site by publishing scientific based data.
25
John s
July 26 2017
It looks to me that coffee ha no effect whatsoever on the blood sugar level. The starting blood sugar level was 80, rose very modestly to 85 and ed up at 80. The no coffee day the blood sugar started at 57.5, rose to 77.5 and ended up at 65. WTF???
26
Reply to comment #19 by Bjarte Bakke
Elwin
July 26 2017
Bjarte I am a Member
27
B. D.
July 27 2017
I have found that coffee does raise my back most of the time.. but not always. I make strong coffee in a French press and most of the time it does raise my bs. I never add things to my coffee , I just drink it black. If you add milk or cream you have the dates and natural sugars that need to be counted and factored in.. I would imagine milk would prolong the high blood sugar levels. Though not drinking coffee is better for my bs, drinking it makes me happy and much nicer to be around.. so I try to drink more water before my cup of coffee, which I found helps some.
28
Karen Stewart
July 27 2017
I've been drinking coffee since I was 5 year's old and much blood sugar level is normal who ever believe in that needs to get there head examine
29
Keith
July 27 2017
Not enough information about whether the two readings were taken under exactly the same conditions ie time of day, activity, food eaten before t=0 etc.

What is apparent is that after not eating or drinking for 4 hours your BG drops to 65 as opposed to drinking coffee approx 77. So as mentioned drinking coffee at first sight appears to keep your BG stable but there is not enough information and the reasons why blood sugar levels rise and fall can involve a different pathway each time. The body is always using energy the best way possible.

My guess is that the sudden drop in BG ten minutes after drinking coffee could be caused by adrenaline or perhaps the incretin hormones from the gut are rising which will increase insulin production that results in the momentary drop in BG.

I have also heard that it is well known that coffee assists with fat burning. If this is the case then since Bjarte is keto adapted he may be approaching fasting BG level after 2 hours but by drinking coffee he further stimulates fat burning (lypolysis) which increases the output of Free Fatty Acids and Glucose from the liver as it breaks down the flow of triglycerides coming from the adipose tissue. The increase in glucose production from the liver would explain the BG 77 being above the fasting 65.
30
kate
July 27 2017
My body feelings tell me your findings could be possibly true, coffee does boost my performabce. But what I am more interested is a whole day cycle. Because a few more hours later I will feel more tired compared to I don't drink coffee. I guess when blood sugar decreases, it is our body to send signal to our brain to eat and rest, while we exhaust us by drinking coffeez
31
PulsarH
July 27 2017
My guess this is insignificant change due to many variables... by the way your activity level can affect blood sugar too.
However there may be a slight effect on either insulin or Glucagon secretion; thus might decrease or increase blood sugar.

Vjarte Bakke, Did you established the base line of your fasting levels for many days or you just picked a random one day fasting?

Thanks for the post ... very helpful
32
Sam zayn
July 27 2017
It's well known that carbs are diabetics worst nightmare let's be realistic all this other info.that says otherwise is a bunch of hog wash and most so called diet doctors are scamms that prey on people's vaurnability ...for money or statues
33
Sam zayn
July 27 2017
It's all in the food we eat ...everything is injected with hormones for bigger bottom line
34
YukonBlend
July 27 2017
Unless done with proper scientific methods, your data is garbage & any conclusions drawn from it are garbage as well. You are doing your readership a huge disservice by publishing this. Shame on you.??
35
Dwight
July 27 2017
Qustion; did you drink anything else on those days you when you weren't drinking coffee? A raise in glucose, although it was mofest, might just be a response to food despite it having little carbs in it. Kind of a Pavlovian response.
36
Subramanian Ramajayam
July 27 2017
I do not think drinking coffee will upset the blood sugar control,if taken without sugar.
37
Richie
July 27 2017
The problem is the testing will never be exact because your body changes day to day for a diabetic it's even worse even if you ate and drank the exact same thing in the same amount ever day it would never match everything impacts your body including time of day amount of sleep sunshine
38
Joyce E Liberty-Clayton
July 27 2017
I'm a diabetic and prior to being diagnosed with the disease in 2003, I had been a pot-a-day caffeinated black coffee drinker, until I quit drinking the beverage around that time. I recall mentioning to my husband that as long as I was drinking coffee I had no issues with blood sugar. Anyway, there are so many variables involved in your sugar spikes and plunges on days when you drink coffee; what you've eaten plays a large role, so ...
39
Reply to comment #21 by LowCarbArcher
Bjarte Bakke Team Diet Doctor
July 27 2017

Wait, was your diet exactly the same for the two days? You day nothing about what else you consumed.

I ate ketogenic both days and similar foods but not exactly the same. I didn't eat anything 10 hours before the experiment, and nothing during the experiment.

Sleep, stress, and activity levels were all similar both days.
40
Reply to comment #22 by Tobias
Bjarte Bakke Team Diet Doctor
July 27 2017

I wouldn't be surprised if the results next time can be just the opposite.

Fair point, the results could be random variability.
41
Reply to comment #23 by Dr. Kenneth Solomon
Bjarte Bakke Team Diet Doctor
July 27 2017

Actually if you haven't consumed any food during this time your blood glucose is at a healthier level with the caffeine (coffee). Your levels without it actual border on hypoglycemia. There has been a great deal of data testing caffeine (black coffee) and its effects on blood sugar. The results have been either neutral or a positive effect, meaning more often in the normal range.

I'm in ketosis and therefore less sensitive to lower levels of blood glucose.
42
Dindo
July 27 2017
Your experiment is illogical..everybody knows that coffee has zero sugar content and I think it also has no carb component..so trace back what you ate previous or prior to taking that experiment. .like low glycemic index food takes sometime to become sugar.

Replies: #43, #48
43
Reply to comment #42 by Dindo
Victor
July 27 2017
Caffeine is a stimulant and as such it is a reasonable hypothesis that perhaps it triggers the body to release glucose.

Your experiment is illogical..everybody knows that coffee has zero sugar content and I think it also has no carb component..so trace back what you ate previous or prior to taking that experiment. .like low glycemic index food takes sometime to become sugar.
44
Sina matata
July 27 2017
Am glad to see this testing or research, whatever we can call it. I am a type 2 dietetic on metformin 1000 (bid). I love to take a cup of coffee every morning. However, to get a helpful research on the effects of coffee on dietetics will depend on many factors, what you are before, either active or not, what was in the coffee, was it decaffeinated, or caffeinated, and many other things. Please consider those, and it will help many of us. Thanks for what you are doing.
45
Gerry Richards
July 27 2017
I drink coffee all day everyday as I own a coffee shop also type 2 diabetes and There is no way sugar levels raise drinking coffee Gerry Richards
46
Rita Gomez
July 27 2017
How do you make your coffee, with sugar, flavored syrup? Do you put creamer, skinny or whole milk? I believe those elements matter unless you take your coffee black and no sweetener whatsoever.
47
Ginger
July 27 2017
While yes your drinking black coffee (As it was clearly stated people) did you eat the exact same foods and portions both days, that is truly the only way to know considering different foods have different levels of sugars and different portion sizes are going to change that as well I would love to know the results on two separate days of eating the exact same thing drinking the exact same amount while consuming the exact same amount of coffee. I'm a coffee drinker myself and I have type 2 diabetes I can't even imagine having to give up my coffee but if it makes that much of a difference I think I would just do it but I don't have it in me to try to do the research myself LOL
48
Reply to comment #42 by Dindo
Rainday
July 28 2017
It sounds illogical, but I can tell you that caffeine affects blood sugar. Type one diabetic here. Whenever I drink coffee or energy drinks, my blood sugar spikes. So there.
(And no, I do not take sugar in my coffee and I only drink sugar-free energy drinks)
49
Michelle
July 28 2017
Coffee can absolutely raise insulin levels. Caffeine causes a response from the adrenals, adrenaline well known, but also cortisol. Cortisol induces pancreatic release of insulin. Which may be why you saw the dip initially, then if you wind up hypoglycemic after the cortisol/insulin surge then the liver starts dumping glucose from its stores to bring it back up...and when this happens and body is reacting to hypoglycemia it usually overshoots the target and the. Lois sugar is higher than if no coffee and a low carb breakfast.
50
Kyle
July 29 2017
So, comparing the glucose values between the "tests," the only conclusion is that there is no difference with respect to acceptable 2 hour fasting values (<140mg/dL). Variations in the range of your comparison values have no biological significance (especially with no established baseline), in addition to the numerous other flaws with even considering this an experiment, pointed out by others. When you do things like this, please share with your readers the normal clinical range expected for these values so they understand your graph doesn't show anything.
51
Andrew Kawasaki
September 7 2019
With the caveat that the experimental error is not known, but may be approximated, (i.e., draw a line through the points of a section of the graph, e.g., time: 120-180 min), it appears to me that: blood sugar levels with coffee showed no significant change during the period of time = 120 min ("drank coffee"), to time = 180 min or 240 min; while blood sugar levels without coffee DID show significant change during the period of time = 120 min, to time = 180 min or 240 min. I know Dr Bakke did subsequent experiments, so now I need to follow up on those. I just wanted to view what was done. Yes, this experiment may not be perfect, but I commend Dr Bakke for taking the time and effort to conduct it! As long as one understands the limitations of the experiment, Dr Bakke's results are helpful, add to the database, and furthermore interesting! Thank you Dr Bakke!
52
Lesia Ledford
May 27
I believe that the days you drink coffee will be higher. experiencing that now
And I love my coffee but it’s been crazy
53
Giselle
August 22
Does this apply to type 1 diabetics?

Reply: #54
54
Reply to comment #53 by Giselle
Kristin Parker Team Diet Doctor
August 23

Does this apply to type 1 diabetics?

Please note that this was a single subject, self-conducted experiment. The best way to know if a certain food or drink affects you is to monitor your blood sugar.