The seed-planting specialities

Farmer’s hand planting seed in soil

Anne Mullens recently wrote about the five stages of keto eating. On her list, number 5 was advocacy, which comes after elation (getting good results for yourself and feeling quite happy about it), personal promotion (telling family and friends about it, whether they want to hear it or not), and irritation/anger (how can this not be standard treatment yet?!).

Low carb advocacy with limited time

Advocacy is when you think that you must do your part to help spread the word wider than your personal circle, that you must help correct the misinformation, and that you must start ignoring the old guard. Adapted to doctors, it could include feeling like you must convince your patients to give it a try.

But what if you are not a family physician seeing patients mainly in a clinic, and are without the option to follow them up longitudinally? What if you literally have only minutes to see each patient for their regular issues, like in subspecialised ophthalmology, or only see them in difficult contexts such as in the emergency department or on the palliative care unit?

What can you do if you believe the science supporting the low carb and keto diets, and your personal experience has convinced you of the concrete benefits for your health, weight, and well-being, and you have in front of you a patient who really should be eating low carb but obviously knows nothing about it?

I recently surveyed my medical colleagues in all specialties across Canada. If giving a full lesson on nutrition and metabolism is nearly impossible for most, the vast majority can still mention it to patients. And many do. Mentioning it is a way to advocate and spread the word.

We can call this planting seeds.

Planting seeds

female doctor writing a prescriptionPlanting seeds does not require a lot of time, but it does require a little bit of faith. You have to believe in your heart that it’s the right thing to do, whether or not you think the patient in front of you will jump on that wagon, or, should I say, whether or not you think this seed will turn into a plant and flourish.

My own personal clinical experience has shown me I am not very good at guessing which seed will turn into a plant and which will dry up and die, or stay dormant for now. It’s very similar to counseling patients to quit smoking. The fact that our success rate isn’t 100% does not mean we should stop counselling patients to leave that poison behind.

So, across Canada, which specialities, aside from family medicine, actually counsel patients and colleagues on low carb, and how much time does it take them?

  • Anesthesia, from 1 to 3 min. Before they fall asleep, that is.
  • Anesthesia, working in pain clinic, around 2-3 minutes.
  • Cardiac surgery, about 5-10 minutes, but not during surgery.
  • Cardiology, a few minutes, to get to the heart of the problem.
  • Dermatology, 5 minutes, especially with patients with acanthosis nigricans and PCOS.
  • Emergency Medicine, less than 3 minutes, especially with patients with sky-high sugar levels.
  • Gastroenterology, around 5-10 min, especially with patients with fatty liver and IBS.
  • General Surgery, 5-10 minutes, especially for diabetes control and weight loss prior to most major surgery, in particular hernia repair.
  • Gynecology, 10-15 minutes, in particular to PCOS patients, infertility patients and peri-/post-menopausal women.
  • Hemato-Oncology, a few minutes, to discuss reduced risk of some malignant disease as well as the non-oncology health benefits, for example.
  • Hepatology, anywhere from 5 to 40 minutes per patient! Because fatty liver, you know!
  • Infectiology, a few minutes, mainly to patients with diabetes and osteitis.
  • Internal Medicine, to most patients who are overweight or have diabetes, about 5 to 15 minutes, or 1h if they come specifically for dietary counselling.
  • Microbiology, 5-10 minutes, mainly for obese or patients with diabetes with infected wounds.
  • Ophthalmology, 5-10 minutes.
  • Opiate addiction medical clinic, 5-10 minutes.
  • Orthopedic, less than 3 minutes.
  • Palliative care, less than 20 minutes.
  • Pathology, counselling staff, family and friends, but not so much patients, for obvious reasons….
  • Pediatrician, a few minutes.
  • Peds neuro, a few minutes, especially to migraine patients.
  • Physiatry, less than 5 minutes, often to migraine patients.
  • Plastic surgery, 5-10 minutes, to numerous patients.
  • Psychiatry, about 10-20 minutes.
  • Radiology, usually while performing an ultrasound (fatty liver) or biopsy, around 5-15min, if not less than 1 minute. Captive audience!.
  • Respirology/sleep medicine: about 1-5 minutes.
  • Rhumatology, around 5 minutes per patient.
  • Other specialties not listed here: they may not have seen my post!

Asian woman lying down while female doctor is doing an ultrasound on her stomachThe bottom line is that every specialty can help spread the word. There might never be a perfect day when you’re ahead of schedule, a perfect context, perfect patients. There might just be you, doing the best that you can with the resources that you have, and patients suffering from chronic illnesses related to their lifestyle. They don’t know their food choices are harming them. But you do.


The one-minute speech

rxWhat I personally found useful is to give patients my one-minute speech, and then a few resources they can check out to get more information, such as the Obesity Code, DietDoctor, and a summary sheet that I created (in French). A colleague of mine. Dr. Hala Lahlou, has also produced a pamphlet (also in Molière’s language), and Youtube videos. It’s convenient to direct patients there. I tell my patients to book an appointment with me if they’re interested in giving food a try as a therapeutic option.

If all you have is that one encounter with the patient in front of you, give them at least a one-minute speech, and resources. Plant that seed.

Here’s a one-minute speech from Dr. David Unwin, general practitioner in the UK, quoted with his permission:

You have multiple chronic health problems. All of which are associated or caused by lifestyle habits. There are a couple of ways we can go at this point: continue down the lifelong medication route, and you’ll probably need more meds overtime, and we’ll see how that goes, or there is a very promising alternative pathway, which is looking at diet. I’ll give you a diet sheet, and if you stick to it, we probably won’t need more meds. In fact, we may even be able to deprescribe some of them. You will probably lose weight, you will probably feel less hungry, and you’ll probably feel better.

Which do you want to choose?

Doctors from all specialties can make a difference

Any doctor from any specialty can adapt this simple speech to suit their context, and have a prescription pad with a few resources already printed on it. It really doesn’t need to take a lot of time. But it makes a difference, whether you end up seeing the results or not.

Protect nature

So, plant that seed whenever you can. And have a little faith.

Dr. Èvelyne Bourdua-Roy


Keto for beginners

Earlier with Dr. Bourdua-Roy

Do you want to read more by Evelyne? Here are her three most popular posts:
  • ’Keto Crotch’: the latest myth?
  • The scale and its other liar acolytes
  • Nicole’s case: keto solves lifelong obesity and food issues

All earlier posts by Dr. Bourdua-Roy

Low-carb basics

Success stories

Low-carb doctors

Weight loss

Older posts