Free trial

“I’m still hungry on a keto diet!”

June 23 2018 by , medical content by in Intermittent fasting, Keto, Low carb & high fat, Q&A, Weight loss
askdrandreaseenfeld

Does MCT oil help with weight loss? Why are you still hungry on keto? And can you get too high ketones?

Get the answers in this week’s Q&A with Dr. Andreas Eenfeldt:

MCT oil to help weight loss?

I was diagnosed as pre-diabetic. I’m 55, 5’3″ (160 cm) but 135 lbs (61 kg). Have been on strict keto diet for 3½ weeks. Not counting carbs but avoiding all foods not on the low-carb spectrum. No weight loss yet! Should I take MCT oil?

Marilyn

 
No. MCT oil does not help with weight loss. If you want to speed things up I recommend adding intermittent fasting instead. Bonus: it’s free.

Best,
Andreas Eenfeldt

Hungry on keto

I have been on the ketogenic diet for almost nine months. I eat between 120-140 grams of fat, 84 g protein and 20-25 g of net carbs per day. I’m very hungry! My weight loss has stalled so I have attempted to reduce to 100 g but feel soooooo hungry! I started supplementing with B5.

What could this hunger mean? Any tips?

Giulia

 
Hi Giulia!

Hard to say without knowing more, like your height and weight. For some reason, it seems like your body feels you’ve reached your ideal body weight and it does not want to lose more. So perhaps you have? Or, if definitely not the case, there may be other hormonal issues involved. Also – if applicable – remember that women 40+ sometimes may have to accept that they don’t have the same body weight as when they were younger, for hormonal reasons. The alternative can be a need for starvation that is rarely sustainable or empowering.

For more options see our guides:

Best,
Andreas Eenfeldt

 

Is it possible to have your ketones go too high by IF and a keto diet?

I recently lost 40 lbs (18 kg) on keto and then it stalled out and now I am gaining weight doing the same keto diet. My ketones are consistently around 2.0. When I did three 24-hour fasting days consecutively, the ketones hit 4.9. Now I have gained 8 lbs (4 kg) back eating three times a day. Please help me figure this out. My blood work has been amazingly good, but I seem to still need insulin. What do I do? Do I fast?

Ron

 
Hi Ron!

As long as you feel fine, 4.9 in ketones should not be any cause for concern. Regarding fasting, we generally do not recommend fasting more than 24-48 hours. This can be highly effective and there is rarely a need for longer fasting than that.

Best,
Andreas Eenfeldt

More

Keto for beginners

Intermittent fasting for beginners

How to lose weight

More questions and answers

Many more questions and answers:

Low-carb Q&A

Q&A

  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Is low carb bad for exercise?
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Is low carb bad for the kidneys?
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Everything in moderation?
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Is low carb bad for the environment?
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Is low carb an extreme diet?
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Are there potential dangers with a low-carb diet?
  • Women's questions introduction
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    What is the main benefit of low carb?
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Does the brain need carbohydrates?
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Can low carb and keto help with PMS?
  • Is low carb bad for gut bacteria?
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Why is low carb important to you?
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Can low carb make menopause easier?
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Is low carb bad for the thyroid?
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Is there a link between low carb and eating disorders?
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Can you get depressed on low carb?
  • Is saturated fat bad?
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Can fasting be problematic for women?

Videos with Dr. Eenfeldt

  • MEMBERS ONLY
    A global food revolution
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Weight control, the calories vs. insulin theory
  • A global food revolution
  • Update from Sweden
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    The food revolution
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Diet & diabetes – how to normalize your blood sugar
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Weight loss and type 2 diabetes reversal on low carb – is it sustainable?
  • A global food revolution
  • Weight control – calories or insulin
  • A global food revolution
  • Q&A with Dr. Andreas Eenfeldt
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Keto for beginners: Side effects
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Q&A about low carb and sugar
  • Keto for beginners: Weight loss
  • The 5 common mistakes on LCHF
  • Keto for beginners: How it works
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Keto for beginners: Health effects
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Keto for beginners: 7 steps to ketosis

More with low-carb doctors

  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Part 8 of Dr. Jason Fung's diabetes course
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    "Humans are not broken by default"
  • Can low carb make it fun to be a doctor?
  • How to help patients reverse type 2 diabetes
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Tim Noakes on trial
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    The human body needs good saturated fats — Dr. Ken Berry
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    LCHF and diabetes: science and clinical experience
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Launching the Diet Doctor podcast
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Challenging the dogma
  • A global food revolution
  • Diet Doctor Podcast #26 – Dr. Ignacio Cuaranta
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Why more protein is better
  • Diet Doctor Podcast #36 with Eric Westman
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    How to prevent chronic disease – Dr. Trudi Deakin
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    "I make a difference every day"
  • A low-carb story with Dr. Campbell Murdoch
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    He questioned his own beliefs
  • MEMBERS ONLY
    Weight loss and type 2 diabetes reversal on low carb – is it sustainable?

14 comments

  1. 1 comment removed
  2. 2
    Irene logan
    June 23 2018
    Is it beneficial to take in ketones? Thank you
  3. 1 comment removed
  4. 4
    Susan
    June 23 2018
    I had a problem with still feeling hungry, even though I was in ketosis (per blood test by doctor). Not only was I hungry, but I was also having hypoglycemic episodes almost every morning. And I wasn't losing weight, nor was my A1c coming down. What I discovered is that I was eating WAY too much protein for my height and ideal weight -- probably twice to three times as much as I actually could utilize. When I moderated my protein intake to an amount appropriate for my height and ideal weight, I started feeling better immediately, and the weight/A1c came tumbling down.
    Replies: #5, #16
  5. 5
    Reply to comment #4 by Susan
    Kathleen
    June 25 2018
    Good to know. Thanks.
  6. 6
    Kathy
    June 27 2018
    Susan, how did you come up with a protein number for you height and ideal weight?
  7. 7
    rosie
    June 28 2018
    Hi I was trying to lose weight with a Ket diet with not a lot of success until I dropped my carbs to zero and the weight has been coming off consistently. I do have a few leaves now and then but I find keeping my carbs really low my hunger is abated and I am satiated. Watch Dr Ted Naiman interview 'why more protein is better '. I'm 59 and this approach has worked really well for me .
  8. 8
    Gizelle
    June 28 2018
    Rosie, thank you for your advise, that maybe the way I have to go also. I am also 59, healthy and fit, 5.2" high and 144 pound when I began keto. I was vegan previously, on keto I eat eggs, fish and low carb dairy, low carb green vegetables, coconut oil or butter, cream in coffee. Was on keto for 4 months, lost 1.5 kg in the beginning then nothing for a month. Started HCG injection trough a weightless clinic and that helped me to louse an other 2 kg in two weeks. Continue with keto and zero weight loss. Fasted about 10 days with no result. After four moths I ended keto as I was filling ill, fisically and mentally. High exsaity, fast heart rate kept me up at night, week and tired physically, very stressed and inpatient with people. I felt my skin hanging from my face. Had blood test that showed high cholesterol level, low white blood cells and some other issues I am not familiar with. The symptoms I experienced are completely goes agains keto diet's supposed benefits.
  9. 9
    Bradley
    June 28 2018
    Re: Hungry and not loosing weight...

    Through my exhaustive trials and tribulations I have found that if you loose a substantial amount of weight your body wants to protect itself, so, you stop loosing weight. In time your body kind of goes hey, no crisis here and the weight starts to disappear again. Along with this I have also found that I will level off, and then gain weight (muscle increase), then loose weight. If I may, measure by physical size and scale not just scale.

    As for the hunger, my experience has been, and continues to be, if Im getting hungry I was not eating enough fat or protein. I would find new was to increase the fat as much as I could while only increasing the protein modestly.

    For me this was done through fat loaded scrambled eggs:

    2 eggs;
    1/4 cup 35% cream;
    1 cup cheese (cheddar Shredded);
    2 TS of salted butter to cook in;
    Salt, pepper and hot sauce to taste.

    2 g of carbs
    34.5 g of protein
    83.5 g of fat

    This always filled me up for hours and eventually was no longer needed as a boost. It is now Saturday or Sunday breakfast. Yes, it is a lot of dairy but I found that some time after removing breads and the like I had no issues with dairy.

    Hope this helps or lends itself to an idea or two.

  10. 10
    Jen
    September 24 2018
    Your comment on hunger I believe is wrong. To say "remember that women 40+ sometimes may have to accept that they don’t have the same body weight as when they were younger, " that's just negative. Maybe people have lost muscle mass but to say they need to basically settle. Wrong.
  11. 11
    Warren
    December 28 2018
    I like Jen, great comment rebuttal. I agree totally. Women are resilient and amazing. They do way more than any man does with their bodies. I believe if a gal puts her mind to being regimental about a ketogenic diet. Follows the macronutrient guide for her height weight and age. She can go back to exactly what she looked like in her prime. Unless in her prime she was struggling, in which case she can get to her optimal weight no matter what. Ketones will always burn the fat stores that are on our bodies no matter what and when there is no more fat stores. we will either have to eat enough fat to keep ketones motivated in our liver. or we will slightly have to change our diet and reduce the amount of fat intake. Remembering to remain on a low carb budget, and drink lots of water. And how are you post it
  12. 12
    Rajan Rajan
    January 14 2019
    Hi i started the keto diet and im body building. Im not getting full always feeling hungry. Any suggestions
  13. 13
    Shaz
    January 26 2019
    I feel hungry all the time even if I have 3 meals on keto diet haven't lost wieght what do i do i feel very hungry on a night can't sleep pls give me advice
  14. 14
    Edgar
    March 24 2019
    While Keto has helped me lower my fasting blood glucose, I haven't been able to lose weight and I'm about 150 pounds overweight. I will lose like 6 to 8 pound the first week and then that's it. I guess I probably fall in that category that needs to eat 20 grams or lower of carbs. I eat around 50 to 70. I do eat breaded meats, drink wine but also since I am not eating starchy carbs, i tend to load up a lot more on protein, cheese which might be derailing my weight loss efforts. Dr Fung states that protein also raises Insulin and for my condition I have to keep insulin low. I have tried intermittent fast skipping breakfast and the best results is that I maintain my current weight despite over eating in the protein department. Should I do complete 1 day fast and work towards a 3 to 5 days fast so I can lose weight?
    Reply: #15
  15. 15
    Reply to comment #14 by Edgar
    Kristin Parker Team Diet Doctor
    March 25 2019

    While Keto has helped me lower my fasting blood glucose, I haven't been able to lose weight and I'm about 150 pounds overweight. I will lose like 6 to 8 pound the first week and then that's it. I guess I probably fall in that category that needs to eat 20 grams or lower of carbs. I eat around 50 to 70. I do eat breaded meats, drink wine but also since I am not eating starchy carbs, i tend to load up a lot more on protein, cheese which might be derailing my weight loss efforts. Dr Fung states that protein also raises Insulin and for my condition I have to keep insulin low. I have tried intermittent fast skipping breakfast and the best results is that I maintain my current weight despite over eating in the protein department. Should I do complete 1 day fast and work towards a 3 to 5 days fast so I can lose weight?

    Before jumping to fasting, you may wish to try lowering your carb count first. You can try our free two week challenge to get a good idea of how to start with very low carbs. You can find some good additional tips here as well.
    https://www.dietdoctor.com/how-to-lose-weight

  16. 16
    Reply to comment #4 by Susan
    Maria
    June 23 2019
    Hi Susan was
    I developed T2 diabetes on 14.5yrs of Atkins, switched to keto A1c started coming down BUT it was only when I reduced protein did all my blood glucose return to normal values and no more dawn phenomenon either.

    For those of us that are hyperinsulinemic [causes hypoglycemia] aka insulin resistant then excess protein IS an issue converted to a process glucose in a process called gluconeogenesis.

    I'm now the lowest weight I've been in 30 yrs [lower protein fixed my weight stall by controlling insulin response better]

    Still 20lbs to go but weight be up and down 5lbs for the past 7 months. However as diabetes in remission and also reversed mild retinophy the health benefits far out weigh a number on the scale.

    I had a problem with still feeling hungry, even though I was in ketosis (per blood test by doctor). Not only was I hungry, but I was also having hypoglycemic episodes almost every morning. And I wasn't losing weight, nor was my A1c coming down. What I discovered is that I was eating WAY too much protein for my height and ideal weight -- probably twice to three times as much as I actually could utilize. When I moderated my protein intake to an amount appropriate for my height and ideal weight, I started feeling better immediately, and the weight/A1c came tumbling down.

    I had a problem with still feeling hungry, even though I was in ketosis (per blood test by doctor). Not only was I hungry, but I was also having hypoglycemic episodes almost every morning. And I wasn't losing weight, nor was my A1c coming down. What I discovered is that I was eating WAY too much protein for my height and ideal weight -- probably twice to three times as much as I actually could utilize. When I moderated my protein intake to an amount appropriate for my height and ideal weight, I started feeling better immediately, and the weight/A1c came tumbling down.

Leave a reply

Reply to comment #0 by

.

Older posts