Does Fat Cause Type 2 Diabetes?

Ask Dr. Jason Fung

  • Does fat cause type 2 diabetes?
  • How common is it that people reverse type 2 diabetes, using fasting and low carb, and over what period of time?
  • Should you use carb counting or glycemic index counting?

Dr. Jason Fung is one of the world’s leading experts on fasting for weight loss and diabetes reversal. Here are a his answers to those questions and more:

What proportion of patients at your clinic succeed in reversing diabetes, and over what period of time?

It would be interesting to have some reference points for people with different starting BMI’s and duration of diabetes – but any figures would be good: e.g. Of people with an initial BMI over 40 and diabetes over 10 years, x% had reversed it after 3 months, y% after 6 months and z% after 1 year.

Barbara

It all depends on motivation and compliance. I don’t have hard numbers on compliance but my ballpark estimate is that only about half the patients in the clinic are compliant. Our Long Distance Program has much higher compliance, maybe 60-70%.

People who are not complying, i.e. they are not really following the program, have little chance of benefit. Of those that comply, I would estimate that 80% show improvement in their type 2 diabetes. However, to get complete reversal often takes years or more. The disease of type 2 diabetes takes decades or more to develop and does not go away fully in 2 weeks. That’s only wishful thinking. Also, if you return to the diet that gave you type 2 diabetes, the disease will return.

The most important factors in how long it takes is how severe your type 2 diabetes is, and how long you’ve had it (along with compliance). If you fast once or twice a week for 24 hours, it could take many years to fully reverse, if ever. If you do repeated, prolonged fasts, it may happen sooner. Doing a low-carb diet between fasts will also speed things up.

But the bottom line is this – if you don’t eat, yes, you will lose weight and reduce your blood sugars in type 2 diabetes. It is almost 100% effective.

Dr. Jason Fung

Learn more:

Does fat cause type 2 diabetes?

I am currently using this site for recipes; I have been addicted to sugar, mother died from kidney failure as a result of diabetes, father is following the same path (has diabetes, on dialysis). When I am on LCHF diet I feel great, clear, no fog, depression is less of an issue, and I have energy.

Along comes this link I get: http://nutritionfacts.org/2016/11/17/fat-is-the-cause-of-type-2-diabetes

I understand that in addition to research, you have hundreds of people to use as clinical evidence against this. Where in this article are they going wrong science-wise? Is there something I should be aware of regarding fat and type 2 diabetes?

Krista

I do not believe that dietary fat causes type 2 diabetes. The proof is in the pudding. We’ve followed the advice to lower dietary fat and type 2 diabetes prevalence has increased dramatically. Common sense alone would tell us that this theory is likely untrue.

In this video, the doctor is correct in saying that fat found within muscle causes insulin resistance (fatty muscle). However, this ‘fatty muscle’ is not caused by EATING dietary fat. Instead eating refined carbohydrates and high insulin levels causes de novo lipogenesis in the liver which is exported to the muscles as VLDL and causes ‘fatty muscle’.

This same effect is seen in cattle where cows are fed high starch grain to cause ‘marbling’ of the beef, which is nothing more than ‘fatty muscle’. But it’s important to note that eating too many CARBS, not FAT causes this ‘fatty muscle’.

Dr. Jason Fung

Carb counting or glycemic index counting?

Hello Dr. Jason!

Is it the amount of carbs that plays a role or the glycemic index of the meal? If the second, maybe a cake full of fiber and low glycemic index sugar like coconut sugar could have lower glycemic index than a steak? Maybe carbophobia is not the optimum diet and carbs with low glycemic index are fine, even if the amount of carbs is high? Thanks!

Bill

In my opinion, it’s not carbs or glycemic index that causes obesity. Instead it’s the insulin response that is important. Therefore, I don’t think that carb counting or glycemic index captures what is most important.

Instead, it would be more useful to look at an ‘insulin index’. Marty Kendall at www.optimisingnutrition.com has done some excellent work in this area and estimates the insulin effect of foods as the net carbs (carbs minus fibre) plus half of protein.

It is important to understand that one can eat large amounts of carbohydrates and still have a small insulin effect, as proven by the Kitavan studies of Dr. Lindeberg. Carbohydrates are an important factor in the insulin response, but not the only effect – vinegar, fibre, dietary fat, protein, incretin effect and insulin resistance all play a role in determining the insulin response.

Dr. Jason Fung

 

More

Intermittent Fasting for Beginners

How to Reverse Type 2 Diabetes – The Quick Start Guide

Earlier Q&A sessions with Dr. Fung:

Many more questions and answers:

Intermittent Fasting Q&A

Read all earlier questions and answers – and ask your own! – here if you are a member:

Ask Jason Fung about intermittent fasting and type 2 diabetes – for members (free trial available)

Q&A videos

  • What is the main benefit of low carb?
  • Isn't weight loss all about counting calories?
  • Everything in moderation?

More Q&A videos (for members) >

Top Dr. Fung videos

  • How to maximize fat burning
  • The top 5 tips to make fasting easier
  • The top 5 myths of fasting

Full IF Course (for members) >

More with Dr. Fung

Dr. Fung has his own blog at intensivedietarymanagement.com. He is also active on Twitter.

His book The Obesity Code is available on Amazon.

The Obesity Code

His new book, The Complete Guide to Fasting is also available on Amazon.

cover2

Leave a reply

Reply to comment #0 by

Older posts