Recent headlines are filled with proclamations that ‘Meat Kills!’ Nothing sells newspapers like the old chestnuts – meat kills!, saturated fat is bad! Let’s take a quick look at this most recent study see if we can draw some conclusions. The study was called ‘Association of Animal and Plant Protein Intake with All-Cause and Cause-Specfic Mortality‘, and published in JAMA Internal Medicine.
This took data from the Nurses’ Health Study and the Health Professionals Follow-up Study, a large prospective cohort. This means they followed 131 342 patients over decades, asking them what they ate. Some of them will die or develop other illnesses and then they look at the database collected to see if there are any associations. You can’t make any inference of causality, but many people do anyway. Why not? Because these are only associations.
In this study, they asked people what they ate and classified it as animal or vegetable protein. Plant protein included bread, cereals, pasta, nuts, beans and legumes. Processed meats were bacon, hot dogs, salami, bologna sausage and kielbasa. When taking a cohort group like this, you need to see whether the groups you are comparing differ in other respects other than just the eating of meat vs. vegetable. Turns out, there was a substantial difference.
For example, those eating more plant protein were also more physically active and smoked less. So, in order to level the playing field, researchers make an adjustment. But what’s the proper adjustment? Here’s the problem. You can make any adjustment you like. For example, how much should you adjust for physical activity? You could argue that you should adjust mortality by anywhere from 5% to 100%. It’s meaningless and anytime you see the word ‘adjusted’, just understand that it means the authors made it up. In addition, we could never adjust for every healthy or unhealthy habit in which the groups differ, the so-called healthy user bias.
After their internally agreed upon adjustment, for every 10% increase in animal protein intake, the hazard ratio for death is 1.02 (not statistically significant) and 1.08 for cardiovascular death (significant but incredibly small increased risk). So, the conclusion is that you don’t die more often, but when you die, you are very slightly more likely to die of heart attacks and strokes. But here’s what they don’t tell you. If you accept that conclusion, then eating less animal protein gives you fewer heart deaths, it may also INCREASE YOUR RISK OF DYING FROM SOMETHING ELSE. Funny, I didn’t see that mentioned in any of the articles on how ‘meat kills’.
So, with a little razz-ma-razz, you can instead generate a sexy headline like ‘Meat KILLS’, why not? As an author, you generate increased prominence in the academic field.
Is there some truth to the statement that meat kills?
But let’s see if we can actually get something useful from this. When looking at the raw data, you can see that one data point really stands out, and it certainly is not meat versus vegetable protein. The data point that really drives the results is the processed meats. There seems to be a bigger disadvantage to eating processed meat. Does that make sense? Sure.
So, in this bologna pictured above, which looks appetizingly like sliced turkey or chicken, it actually contains corn syrup, sodium lactate, sodium phosphates, autolyzed yeast, sodium dictate, sodium erythorbate (made from sugar), sodium nitrite, dextrose extractives, potassium phosphate, sugar, and potassium chloride. But here’s the secret. Corn syrup is sugar. dextrose extractives are sugar, sugar is sugar – this ingredient shows up 3 times in the list. Autolyzed yeast is MSG. It’s all sugar and MSG to make things taste good.
Does it seem reasonable to lump this meat concoction together with grass-fed fresh beef? Hardly. This brings us back to one of the key messages of LCHF. Eat real food. Don’t eat processed carbohydrates. But also just as important, don’t eat processed meat full of sugar and other additives.
So here’s the real lesson from this study.
- Meat and vegetable proteins are similar in terms of health.
- Don’t eat processed foods. Eat real food. Preferably fresh.
- Beware of overhyped ‘studies’ in the media. The headline usually has little to do with reality.
Top videos about meat
- MEMBERS ONLY
- MEMBERS ONLY
Top videos with Dr. Fung
- MEMBERS ONLY
- MEMBERS ONLY
Earlier with Dr. Jason Fung
More with Dr. FungDr. Fung has his own blog at intensivedietarymanagement.com. He is also active on Twitter.
His book The Obesity Code is available on Amazon.
His new book, The Complete Guide to Fasting is also available on Amazon.