Nina Teicholz in WSJ: “Carbs, good for you? Fat chance!”

Carbs or fat concept Background for blog or webpage. Top view Plate with message. copy space for text.

Americans are more obese than ever before. Since the increased emphasis on low-fat dietary guidelines back in the 1980’s, the obesity epidemic has exploded. But dietary defenders continue to mislead the public and put Americans’ health at risk, even though the guidelines likely have made things worse.

Nina Teicholz discusses the issue in The Wall Street Journal:

A widely reported study last month purported to show that carbohydrates are essential to longevity and that low-carb diets are “linked to early death,” as a USA Today headline put it. The study, published in the Lancet Public Health journal, is the nutrition elite’s response to the challenge coming from a fast-growing body of evidence demonstrating the health benefits of low-carb eating…

The Lancet authors, in recommending a “moderate” diet of 50% to 60% carbohydrates, essentially endorse the government’s nutrition guidelines. Because this diet has been promoted by the U.S. government for nearly 40 years, it has been tested rigorously in NIH-funded clinical trials involving more than 50,000 people. The results of those trials show clearly that a diet of “moderate” carbohydrate consumption neither fights disease nor reduces mortality.

The WSJ: Carbs, good for you? fat chance!

The study Teicholz is referring to is entirely based on weak statistical data, you can read more about the study here.


Should journalists avoid reporting on most food studies?

Could a low-carb diet shorten your life??

Dietary guidelines

Low carb


  1. Cassieoz
    I can't read the article without paying a subscription to WSJ 😡
  2. Robin
    When articles are behind paywalls you really should post them on your website as a .pdf and link to the file so your members can read the article. Nina Teicholz wrote the article she should be able to share here work here freely.
  3. vicki
    +1 - I'd like to read this Op-Ed piece but was frustrated to get stuck at the WSJ paywall.
  4. Rhonda
    Can you please post Nina Teicholz' WSJ article so website members can read it?

Leave a reply

Reply to comment #0 by

Older posts