BMJ stands behind Nina Teicholz’ critique of the US Dietary Guidelines


Here’s another victory for science over dogma. Today, the British Medical Journey has again decided to stand behind science writer Nina Teicholz’ peer-reviewed study from 2015, in which the conclusion was that the American dietary guidelines were founded on a weak scientific foundation, and still fail to be up-to-date with the best science.

Teicholz’ article was heavily criticized by old-school scientists – and 180 angry ones even demanded that the BMJ should retract it. After two independent experts reviewed it again, they have concluded that it is “within the realm of scientific debate”:

We stand by Teicholz’s article with its important critique of the advisory committee’s processes for reviewing the evidence, and we echo her conclusion: ‘Given the ever-increasing toll of obesity, diabetes, and heart disease, and the failure of existing strategies to make inroads in fighting these diseases, there is an urgent need to provide nutritional advice based on sound science.’
– Fiona Godlee, BMJ Editor in Chief

The BMJ: Press Release: Independent Experts Find No Grounds for Retraction of the BMJ Article on Dietary Guidelines


The BMJ Criticism of the Dietary Guidelines Will NOT Be Retracted

TIME: Eat Butter. Scientists Labeled Fat the Enemy. Why They Were Wrong.

The US Dietary Guidelines Expert Committee Said to be “Completely Dissociated” From the Top Level Scientific Community

The British Medical Journal Slams Unscientific and Biased Low-Fat Dietary Guidelines!

Credit Suisse: The Future is Lower Carb, Higher Fat

Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics: Stop Worrying about Saturated Fat!

Headlines All Over the World: The Fear of Fat Was a Mistake from the Beginning

Top Nina Teicholz videos

  • Did the introduction of the dietary guidelines start the obesity epidemic?
  • The US dietary guidelines: why they matter
  • The big fat surprise
  • The unknown story of vegetable oils
    The myth of vegetable oils
  • Why our dietary guidelines are wrong
  • Diet Doctor Podcast #21 Nina Teicholz
    Can red meat kill you?
  • Is the Mediterranean diet healthy?

Leave a reply

Reply to comment #0 by

Older posts